Skip to Content

Leaves To Avoid Composting – The Top 5 Varieties To Not Compost And Why!

While adding fall leaves to your compost pile is great in theory, there are a few leaves you should avoid composting.

Now that the weather has started to cool down, the trees are starting to drop their leaves. It seems like everywhere you look, the ground is covered in orange, red, green, and brown fallen leaves. Not only is it beautiful, it is also a great source of potential energy for gardeners!

Most people simply rake the leaves into piles and either dispose of them or bag them for local pickup. That is, of course, after jumping into the piles a few times! 

Fallen leaves are perfect for home compost piles - most of them!
Fall is a time for cooler temperatures and fallen leaves. While some leaf varieties can be used for making amazing compost, others should be left completely out.

But if you garden or have flowerbeds, they can be put to use for more than just jumping into. Most varieties are perfect for adding to compost piles or for creating leaf mold with a few basic tips. 

Unfortunately, just like not all trees are created the same, not all leaves are created equally either. It’s very important to know which variety you can use in abundance. There are also some you can use sparingly, and some you should avoid adding at all costs. 

What Leaves To Avoid Composting

Since a tree’s leaves have up to 80% of its nutrients, they make a great addition to home compost piles. Not only do they help boost nutrient levels, but they are also a great source of organic matter as the leaves break down.  

While most tree leaves are completely safe and great for home compost piles, learning which types of trees aren’t good for creating amazing (and safe!) compost is important. Not only can the wrong type of leaves slow down the decomposition of your pile, but some leaves can be harmful to your future plants and flowers as well. 

For an in-depth look at composting leaves in general, check out “Composting Leaves, How To Make Great Compost From Leaves”. You’ll find everything you need to know to create amazing black gold using the resources around your home and property.

Now let’s get into what tree leaf varieties you shouldn’t use or ones that you should only use sparingly.

Several black walnut tree leaves on the ground - You should avoid composting black walnut leaves
It’s best if you keep black walnut tree leaves completely out of home compost piles.

1. Black Walnut – Leaves To Avoid Composting

When it comes to gardening and growing plants, you should avoid black walnut trees at all costs. These trees excrete a chemical called juglone. This chemical is in the roots of the tree and also in their nut hulls, stems, and buds. 

Juglone concentrates in high percentages around the tree’s canopy. However, you can also find small amounts of the chemical within the leaves. When you add the leaves to your compost pile, the juglone can break down as it decomposes.  

As you go to use your finished compost the following spring, highly susceptible plants may fail to produce and thrive. In addition, any seeds you plant in soil that has been amended with compost that was created using black walnut leaves might fail to germinate altogether. 

Vegetable plants like asparagus, cabbages, peppers, potatoes, and tomatoes are all highly susceptible. Lilacs, peonies, rhododendrons, and azaleas are also sensitive to juglone. 

While some plants are more tolerant to juglone, it’s best to avoid adding black walnut leaves to compost piles just to be on the safe side.

2. Horse Chestnut – Leaves To Avoid Composting

Horse chestnut trees are a type of shade tree that produces esculin. Esculin is a toxin that concentrates in the brown-colored nuts, bark, buds, and leaves of horse chestnut trees.

Horse chestnut leaves  should be avoided.
Horse chestnut leaves can cause stomach distress and can take a long time to break down.

If you consume esculin in large quantities repeatedly over the course of several years, it can cause stomach issues, vomiting, and other issues. While you don’t directly consume the compost, it can be transmitted to the plants in small doses through the soil.

Because of this, it’s best to just avoid adding them to home compost piles. In addition, horse chestnut leaves take a long time to break down, slowing down your decomposition rate and delaying your use of that nutrient-packed black gold.  

3. Beech – Leaves To Avoid Composting

Beech tree leaves have high amounts of lignin. Lignin is an organic polymer that is present in the bark, wood, and leaves of trees. The more lignin that is present within the leaves, the longer it takes for them to break down. 

With home compost piles, you want to create an environment that can break down quickly and turn into that black gold that gardeners love and need. By adding a bunch of leaves with high levels of lignin, your compost pile decomposition will greatly be impacted.  

Because of this, you should only use beech tree leaves in moderation. Try to not let them make up more than 10% of your leaf compost pile as a whole. 

4. Oak – Leaves To Avoid Composting

Oak trees produce leaves that have a shiny, thick outer layer. Similarly to beech, they also have high levels of lignin. Due to this, they are extremely slow to break down and decompose. 

Oak leaves should only be used in moderation in compost piles.
Whole oak leaves will take forever to break down. While shredding them can help, their high levels of lignin will still cause delays with composition.

In addition to having high levels of lignin, oak leaves are also more acidic than other tree varieties. This can mess up the pH balance of home compost piles. Oak leaves also have lower levels of nitrogen and other nutrients that are really beneficial to homemade compost. So for best results, you should only have 20% of your leaf compost pile be oak leaves. 

5. Holly – Leaves To Avoid Composting 

Holly leaves are another type of tree that contain more lignin than the average tree variety. As mentioned above, lignin causes a delay in the decomposing of compost piles.

In addition, holly leaves are also lower in nitrogen and calcium levels. This makes them not all that helpful for creating nutrient-dense compost. 

The entire goal of creating amazing compost is to have a product that is high in nutrient values and organic matter. So, it’s more beneficial to add tree leaves that can increase the nutrient levels of your compost. Either use holly leaves in moderation or avoid adding them altogether.     

The Best Leaves To Compost

Now that you know what tree varieties to avoid composting or at least limit, what are the best tree varieties? 

Sugar maple tree leaves are perfect for composting.
Not only are sugar maple tree leaves beautiful, but they are perfect for composting!

The top choices to include in home compost piles are maple, elm, ash, birch, cottonwood, poplar, cherry, and other fruit tree leaves.

These varieties have higher concentrations of nutrients within their leaves. All of those nutrients can then transfer into your finished compost piles. In addition, these leaves are able to break down quickly, resulting in completed compost fast.

These freshly fallen tree leaves are an excellent (free!) addition to any home compost pile – As long as you avoid using the above 5 tree varieties or at least keep some of them in moderation!

Simple Garden Life is a website dedicated to keeping gardening fun, simple and enjoyable! We publish two new articles each week along with a new garden podcast episode every two weeks. This article may contain affiliate links.