Skip to Content

How To Make Homemade Birdseed – Feed Birds Better & Cheaper!

Want to know how to make your own nutritious homemade birdseed to feed the birds at your feeders cheaper than ever? Then today’s article is right up your alley!

In order to feed birds healthy, nutritious food, you often have to pay a premium price. Unfortunately, good quality commercial birdseed continues to get more and more expensive each year. And with little hope that it will ever come back down.

But not only can commercial bird feeds be expensive, they also often contain all kinds of unnecessary filler ingredients. Sadly, these useless fillers don’t provide much in the way of nutrients or calories to birds, but they do add to the per pound cost of the feed!

A mixture of homemade birdseed.
Instead of spending loads of money on commercial birdseed products, you can create your own nutritious feed using only the best ingredients – and at a far lower cost!

The winter can be a challenging time for birds that forego migrating to stay at home. Gone are the plants, seeds, and insects that they are used to feeding on during the warmer months. And while using commercial bird food is helpful, most mixes simply don’t provide the birds with the energy they truly need.

But that is exactly where making your own feed at home is the perfect solution. Not only is making birdseed simple, it can also be far less expensive. And best of all, you can give your backyard birds exactly what they need to not just survive, but thrive!

How To Make Nutritious Homemade Birdseed

When making homemade feed for birds, you need to include as many different nutritious ingredients as possible. Birds need a good balance of fats, protein, and fiber. All three of these work in harmony to keep them healthy and strong all year long. 

The great news is that almost all of these ingredients can be purchased in bulk at local feed stores or online. Purchasing in bulk will not only save you time but also money in the long run. Even better, it will help ensure you always have plenty of ingredients on hand to refill those bird feeders!

Choosing Your Ingredients 

There are a whole slew of seeds and natural ingredients you can include in homemade birdseed. But the trick to getting the most bang for your buck is to select seeds and ingredients that are high in nutrients and easier on your wallet. 

A field of red milo
Grain sorghum (also called milo) is often used as a filler in commercial bird feed products. It provides little nutrition to birds and is often not consumed at all.

First and foremost, making your own feed means you can keep out useless filler ingredients such as grain sorghum (i.e., milo) and similar grains. These products add very little nutritious value compared to other available ingredients.

The fillers might be low in cost, but in addition to being low in nutrient value, they are also usually ignored by birds – making them nothing more than a waste of money to include. And even worse, something you have to clean up under the bird feeders!

Keeping You Mix Inexpensive – How To Make Homemade Birdseed

It’s also best to stay away from more expensive ingredients like dried fruits that can cost a fortune. Instead, it’s far better to purchase high-nutrient seeds to make up the bulk of their feed. These can fill their dietary needs completely and stretch your budget. 

It’s not to say you can’t give your birds an occasional treat of fruit, but for day in and day out feeding, it’s best to give them the high energy food they need. And by keeping it affordable, it’s far easier to keep those feeders filled regularly!

Now that you know what items to avoid or to use in moderation, let’s take a look at four of the “best of the best” ingredients to include in homemade birdseed mixes. Not only can all of the ingredients below be purchased in bulk to reduce costs, they also all have incredible nutritional value for birds.

4 Great Ingredients For Homemade Birdseed

Black Oil Sunflower Seeds

Black oil sunflower seeds are one of the absolute best ingredients to add to homemade birdseed mixes. They provide a high fat and fiber content and even provide the birds with some protein.

A bird sitting on a feeder eating black oil sunflower seeds
Black oil sunflower seeds are one of the best seeds of all for feeding birds. They are high in nutrients and fats, and provide birds with big energy.

There are all kinds of varieties of sunflower seeds available. All are wonderful for birds and great for including in your feed mixes, but always be sure to include at least some black oil seeds in the mix. They are by far the best option for high nutritional value, giving you the most value for your money.

Whatever combination of sunflower seeds you include, make sure they are unsalted and unflavored. As much as humans might like spicy, bbq, or ranch-flavored sunflower seeds, they are not exactly great for birds!

You can give sunflower seeds to birds either in or out of the shell. Some smaller birds might have a harder time shelling the seeds, so offering a mixture of both is the best option.  

Popular birds that enjoy sunflower seeds are cardinals, finches, sparrows, goldfinches, woodpeckers, and nuthatches. (Affiliate Product Link: Meadow Ridge Farms Bulk Black Oil Sunflower Seed)

Peanuts

When it comes to getting great nutritional value at a great price, peanuts are a winner for birds! Peanuts are a great source of nutrients and are perfect to add to homemade birdseed mixes.

A blue jay with a whole peanut in the shell in its mouth.
Bigger birds like blue jays have no problem handling peanuts in their shells. To help attract smaller birds though, consider using peeled peanuts.

They are high in fiber and oil and are an excellent source of protein. Best of all, they can be extremely affordable when purchasing in bulk.

Similarly to sunflower seeds, you can add them to your mixture either in or out of the shell. The best option is to use a bit of both in your bird feed since some birds prefer one over the other. Affiliate Product Link: Lyric Peanut Pieces Wild Bird Seed

Birds like blue jays, cardinals, wrens, chickadees, nuthatches, titmice, and woodpeckers all enjoy snacking on peanuts. Blue jays can get a bit aggressive when feeding with other birds, so placing whole peanuts in a separate area can do wonders to keep everyone happy!

Cracked Corn

Cracked corn is another inexpensive ingredient to buy in bulk for adding to bird mixes. Especially in the fall when many local feed mills have plenty on hand! Cracked corn is high in fiber and protein and a wide variety of bird species love snacking on it.

Doves, sparrows, woodpeckers, blue jays, and juncos are all attracted to cracked corn – as are cardinals, quail, starlings, and grosbeaks. In fact, there aren’t many bird species who will turn their nose up to it.

While you can use whole corn kernels, cracked corn is easier for smaller birds to consume. When paired with black oil sunflower seeds, it makes one of the most nutritious and delicious birdseed feeds around.

White Millet

Often confused with milo, white millet makes an excellent addition to homemade birdseed. Both milo and white millet are small and round and often fall out of feeders and end up on the ground. But while the birds will leave the filler milo alone – they love ground snacking on white millet!

White millet, unlike milo, is a great source of calcium, protein, phosphorus, and magnesium for birds. Because of its tiny size, it will often fall out from feeders as birds feed – but this can be especially helpful for birds that like to feed on the ground such as cardinals, doves, sparrows, and thrashers. 

A pile of millet seeded and still on the plant. A great option for homemade birdseed.
Millet provides birds with a ton of different nutrients but little fat, making it a great option to round out your homemade birdseed mixture.

Much as the case with sunflower seeds, peanuts and cracked corn, white millet is much more economical than many of the other bird seed options – and yet, highly nutritious. Affiliate Product Link: Olympus Myco Premium White Proso Millet

Mix & Match – How To Make Homemade Birdseed

By combining these four basic ingredients together to make your own homemade birdseed, you will not only be saving money in your budget but you will also be able to know you are helping to provide a nutritious and tasty feed for your local birds.  

Simply store any unused ingredients in sealed plastic or metal containers and keep them in a dry location until you are ready to use more. 

If you are interested in giving your birds an even bigger boost of energy and calories during the winter months, check out “How To Make Homemade Bird Suet”.

Follow Our Facebook Page For Even More Great Tips! Simple Garden Life Facebook Page

Simple Garden Life is a website dedicated to keeping gardening fun, simple and enjoyable! We publish two new articles each week along with a new garden podcast episode every two weeks. This article may contain affiliate links.